There are some places that flood you with feelings of nostalgia and a longing for the past. They remind you of a simpler time and, hopefully, some very pleasant memories. You know, that local swimming hole, the gas station that’s been around forever or, perhaps, the general store that you stopped by for supplies back when you were a kid. Even if you’ve never been here before, Schooley’s Mountain General Store will surely become a new favorite.

Schooley’s Mountain General store has gone by several names over the years, but dates back to 1830.

Image/Schooley’s Mountain General Store

One of the oldest operating general stores in the country, they have all the grocery essentials - bread, eggs, milk, drinks, chips and more.

TripAdvisor/MitchPhyllis65

They also offer a post office window, pizza shop, sandwiches and catering.

Image/Schooley’s Mountain General Store

Customers rave about the Mountain Subs, but the fresh baked goods (from brownies to bread pudding to apple pie) are also a treat.

Image/Google Maps

Though it’s got old school charm, guests will enjoy modern conveniences like pizza delivery and the opportunity to order deli goods online for pickup. No need to wait while your sandwich is made.

Image/Schooley’s Mountain General Store

You can get a little bit of everything in this spot founded by Joseph Heath, who also owned a local resort.

Flickr/Jimmy Emerson DVM

Visitors once flocked to the area for the pure springs along the nearby mountain. With a high mineral content, many believed they had healing powers.

Flickr/Steven Reynolds

While the springs no longer remain, the area is still stunning with brooks, cascades and Schooley’s Mountain Lake. It’s a great place to hike.

Flickr/Adam Tiner

Notable visitors to the area include the Roosevelts, Astors and Ulysses S. Grant. Schooley’s Mountain General Store is located at 250 Schooleys Mountain Road, Schooleys Mountain. It is open 7 days a week. For more charming old general stores in New Jersey, check out this list.

Image/Schooley’s Mountain General Store

TripAdvisor/MitchPhyllis65

Image/Google Maps

Flickr/Jimmy Emerson DVM

Flickr/Steven Reynolds

Flickr/Adam Tiner

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.