Since 1974, Rusty Barrell Supper Club has been tucked away in an alley off North 14th Street in Ponca City. They have become famous for their signature steaks which have gained them the reputation as “the best little steakhouse in Oklahoma.” But it isn’t easy finding this little-hidden gem. You might be able to follow the smell of mouthwatering steaks, but if you’re looking for an easier way to find this restaurant, continue reading below.
Rusty Barrell Supper Club is located at 2005 North 14th Street in Ponca City.
Victoria C/Yelp
It’s tucked away in a nondescript alley in an industrial building. Look for the orange door about half-way down and enter through it.
travelok.com
Next, you’ll see a doorbell and a wooden door. Ring the doorbell and someone will answer and let you in.
Vitoria C/Yelp
Once inside you might feel like you walked into a speakeasy. The dining room is two stories tall and has a mysterious, yet welcoming ambiance.
travelok.com
It’s the perfect spot to enjoy a date night, special occasion or an evening glass of wine.
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
The menu is full of options, but it’s the mouthwatering steaks that make this place special.
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
The steaks are first-class, aged beef, grilled to perfection and cooked right in the middle of the dining room.
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
Victoria C/yelp
You’ll also find favorites such as chicken, seafood, pork chops and prime rib.
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
And every meal comes with a trip to the incredible salad bar and a fluffy baked potato.
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
Since it’s a popular place in town, expect a wait during busy hours. But don’t worry, if you encounter a wait stop into the lounge and try the Rusty Barrell Surprise - a house specialty drink that is a smooth blend of ice cream and liqueurs.
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
Victoria C/Yelp
travelok.com
Vitoria C/Yelp
bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma/Facebook
Victoria C/yelp
Oklahoma is home to many incredible steakhouses. Check out this list for more around the Sooner State.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
