Tony D S Is The Little Hole In The Wall Restaurant That Serves The Best Pizza In New Jersey

I know that I’m biased but I truly believe New Jersey has the best pizza in the United States. Even if you disagree, it undeniably holds a spot in the top ten places to grab a pie, right up there with Chicago and New York. Everyone has a favorite. In fact, there are many iconic pizzerias in New Jersey, like Star Tavern and DeLorenzo’s. But one lesser-known spot deserves some recognition.

Tony D’s is a local favorite that can be found in Caldwell.

Yelp/Forrest I. It may just be the smallest pizzeria in a town full of pizzerias.

It’s not fancy on the outside, or on the inside.

Facebook/Tony D’s Pizza There’s no dining area, though there is a small patio and a handful of tables.

But it doesn’t need to be with pizza this good.

Yelp/Tony L. Enjoy a classic pie that’s full of flavor. The menu is limited, but every slice is made to perfection. Try the “Drunken Grandma,” with a thin Sicilian crust, fresh mozzarella and housemade vodka sauce.

And you don’t need to take our word for it…

Facebook/Tony D’s Pizza NJ.com recently ranked this pizzeria among the best in the Garden State and customers love it, too. With 4.8 stars on Yelp, they’re definitely doing something right.

And what exactly are they doing right? This spot keeps things simple. If it’s not broken, why fix it? Traditional-style pizzas shine here – no need for wood fired grills or crazy combinations. The old-fashioned pie is a party in your mouth with fresh, flavorful ingredients and the prices are very reasonable. Visit at 3 Hanford Place, Caldwell. If you’re looking for pizza paradise in New Jersey, head to Hoboken. Learn more here.

Yelp/Forrest I.

It may just be the smallest pizzeria in a town full of pizzerias.

Facebook/Tony D’s Pizza

There’s no dining area, though there is a small patio and a handful of tables.

Yelp/Tony L.

Enjoy a classic pie that’s full of flavor. The menu is limited, but every slice is made to perfection. Try the “Drunken Grandma,” with a thin Sicilian crust, fresh mozzarella and housemade vodka sauce.

NJ.com recently ranked this pizzeria among the best in the Garden State and customers love it, too. With 4.8 stars on Yelp, they’re definitely doing something right.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.