We all know by now not to judge a book (or restaurant) by its cover. Some of our best dive restaurants are easy to drive by, if you don’t know the deliciousness that awaits just inside. Here’s another incredible restaurant in Indiana that you probably wouldn’t ever glance twice at.

Mhav2k/Zomato Vito Provolone’s is an amazing Italian restaurant located just north of Greenwood. This restaurant is housed in a run-of-the-mill strip mall and definitely doesn’t stand out from the street. In fact, anyone driving by would likely think this was a standard pizza place, rather than a full-scale Italian food lover’s dream.

Mhav2k/Zomato Once you step inside, however, you know you’ve entered somewhere truly special. The elegant, classy decor and old world Italian ambiance are bound to impress you.

Emily L./Yelp The food, however, is where the real magic of this tiny restaurant springs to life. Even just their basic homemade garlic bread is somehow more melt-in-your-mouth delicious than you ever dreamed bread could be.

Scott M./Zomato For the main course, try one of their classic dishes like their spinach and cheese filled tortellini, complete with marinara and a luscious cheese sauce.

Darcy B./Yelp Or, try a house classic like chicken marsala and lasagna. Vito’s won’t let you down with their interpretation of your favorite classic Italian dishes.

ArmyWife/Zomato You can also create your own specialized Italian dish with their build your own pasta option.

Yelp Are you more of a pizza lover than pasta fan? Don’t worry. Vito’s has amazing pizza, too. They also have incredible desserts (like tiramisu) that you won’t want to turn down.

Vito Provolones/Facebook If you’re looking for great wine, authentic Italian food, and an incredible atmosphere, you’re looking for Vito Provolone’s. Give this hidden gem a try at 8031 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217.

Have you ever been to this small, hidden gem of a restaurant? For more hidden restaurants in Indiana, check out this list.

Mhav2k/Zomato

Vito Provolone’s is an amazing Italian restaurant located just north of Greenwood. This restaurant is housed in a run-of-the-mill strip mall and definitely doesn’t stand out from the street. In fact, anyone driving by would likely think this was a standard pizza place, rather than a full-scale Italian food lover’s dream.

Once you step inside, however, you know you’ve entered somewhere truly special. The elegant, classy decor and old world Italian ambiance are bound to impress you.

Emily L./Yelp

The food, however, is where the real magic of this tiny restaurant springs to life. Even just their basic homemade garlic bread is somehow more melt-in-your-mouth delicious than you ever dreamed bread could be.

Scott M./Zomato

For the main course, try one of their classic dishes like their spinach and cheese filled tortellini, complete with marinara and a luscious cheese sauce.

Darcy B./Yelp

Or, try a house classic like chicken marsala and lasagna. Vito’s won’t let you down with their interpretation of your favorite classic Italian dishes.

ArmyWife/Zomato

You can also create your own specialized Italian dish with their build your own pasta option.

Yelp

Are you more of a pizza lover than pasta fan? Don’t worry. Vito’s has amazing pizza, too. They also have incredible desserts (like tiramisu) that you won’t want to turn down.

Vito Provolones/Facebook

If you’re looking for great wine, authentic Italian food, and an incredible atmosphere, you’re looking for Vito Provolone’s. Give this hidden gem a try at 8031 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.